Showing posts with label innovation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label innovation. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

The Science of Science Policy

I recently discovered the Science of Science Policy website, affiliated to the United States (U.S.) Office of Science and Technology Policy. The U.S. Congress established the Office of Science and Technology Policy in 1976 with a "broad mandate to advise the President... on the effects of science and technology on domestic and international affairs". The goal of the Science of Science Policy community is to "provide a scientifically rigorous and quantitative basis for science policy. The website provides a central location with news, information and research to help inform the Federal Government's science management decisions".

Closely related, the Science of Science and Innovation Policy (SciSIP) program was established at the U.S. National Science Foundation in 2005 in response to a call from John Marburger III for a "specialist scholarly community" to study the science of science policy. The program has three major goals: "advancing evidence-based science and innovation policy decision making; building a scientific community to study science and innovation policy; and leveraging the experience of other countries. A recent Science article highlights some of the issues addressed by SciSIP researchers."

Seventy-five SciSIP awards have been made to date. The awardees include economists, sociologists, political scientists, and psychologists as well as domain scientists. Some recent SciSIP awards (full abstracts available) which might be of interest to readers include Applied Visual Analytics for Economic Decision-Making and Universities, Innovation and Economic Growth. A report in the New York Times, from a couple of years ago, highlights a dataset that SciSIP funded jointly with the Kauffman Foundation, noting that it "tracks government-sponsored research for science and engineering and links it with government start-ups, patents, and other data. One goal of the research is to identify the characteristics of star innovators, scientists who are most effective in ushering research advances into the marketplace."

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Innovation in Education: some Irish success

Amongst the buzz-words one hears a lot about in education these days are innovation and globalization. As this article shows one Irish organization in this field (Hibernia College) is doing well (and doing good too). Curiously enough, it is a for-profit company.

Wednesday, February 09, 2011

Valuation of innovation: The case of iPhone

Korkeamäki, Timo and Takalo, Tuomas (2010): Valuation of innovation: The case of iPhone. Unpublished.

Abstract:

We estimate the private value of Apple’s iPhone by observing abnormal stock market reactions to news announcements and patent publications related to the innovation. Our estimate of the lower bound on the market valuation of iPhone is fairly high, at minimum 30 billion U.S. (event day) dollars. We find that patentable technology explains about 25% of that total value. We also find a weak negative reaction among Apple’s rivals to the news about iPhone but no significant reaction to the publication of patent documents concerning iPhone can be observed. The evidence suggests that the value of iPhone primarily stems from Apple’s management and marketing abilities and efforts rather than from underlying "hard" technologies and intellectual property.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Where do good ideas come from? - RSA Animate and Steven Johnson

Another gem from RSA Animate - Steven Johnson (science writer) on where good ideas come from.

Monday, October 18, 2010

Upcoming Talks on Science, Innovation and the Economy

10th November: Panel Discussion: What's Smart about Ireland's Smart Economy in 2010?
A panel discussion with Dick Ahlstrom (chairman), Science Editor of the Irish Times; Professor John FitzGerald, ESRI; Dr Brian Kelly, CEO of Celtic Catalysts; Karlin Lillington, Technology journalist, Sean O’Driscoll (CEO Glen Dimplex) and Ferdinand von Prondzynski, former President of Dublin City University.

Organisers: Royal Irish Academy and the Irish Times
Admission is free but booking is essential.

11th November: The Long Debate: Debate on the Innovation Taskforce Report

Taking place in the NDRC on the 11th of November, the debate will draw on the findings of the Innovation Taskforce report.

Launched in March 2010, the report sets out recommendations for developing Ireland into an International Innovation Hub. Members of the Taskforce, including some of Ireland’s leading economic commentators, industry and government members, academics, creatives and entrepreneurs will be in attendance to discuss the nature of innovation within Ireland.

Organisers: Inventorium
Debate: 19.00-22.00
NDRC, Crane St, Digital Hub, Dublin 8
Registration for this event is essential.

17th November: Panel Discussion: Can Science be a Business?
A panel discussion with Dick Ahlstrom (chairman), Science Editor of the Irish Times; Professor Luke O’Neill, TCD; Dr Ena Prosser, Fountain Healthcare Partners; Professor Mark O’Malley, UCD; Professor Emmeline Hill (UCD).

Organisers: Royal Irish Academy and the Irish Times
Admission is free but booking is essential.

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Chris Anderson TED Talk

Chris Anderson, who runs TED,  talks about the future and potential innovative potential of online video. One idea in the talk that is interesting is the idea of scientists distributing videos of how exactly they conduct their experiments to facilitate replication. He argues that online video will do for verbal communication what Guttenberg did for written communication. He also argues that it will change teaching and  universities -  "for the first time in human history talented students don't have to have their dreams and potential written out of history by lousy teachers. They can sit two feet in front of the world's finest". Some of the jargon surrounding these initiatives is a little grating but, for want of an alternative, let me go with it. He basically argues that communication in this medium is going from "one-to-many" to "many-to-many", predicting a surge in the amount of people who provide informative content to the online world. He has a nice twist in the end with a clip beamed in from a correspondent living in a Kenyan slum talking about innovative initiatives taking place within his area.

Tuesday, September 07, 2010

Assorted Links: 7th September 2010

1. The Hewlett Packard Social Computing Lab focuses on 'methods for harvesting the collective intelligence of groups of people in order to realise greater value from the interaction between users and information'.

2. "The agony and the ecstasy: the history and meaning of the Journal Impact Factor" (Garfield and Sher, 2005).

3. Measurement of administrative burden imposed on Irish business by Central Statistics Office inquiries

4. http://www.bundle.com: Track your spending

5. DIT School of Computing launches a new master's programme in data analytics

6. A story on the OECD's Education at a Glance 2010, in today's Irish Independent: "For every €7 spent on a primary pupil, nine is spent on second level and 12 is spent on third level".

7. Another Irish Independent story: the mechanics of random selection in the CAO application process

8. Bloomberg Businessweek: The World's 50 Most Innovative Companies

9. Below is a video from the OECD showing the importance of tax credits for understanding government funding of research and development (R&D). When tax credits are taken into account, Korea spends the most (as a percentage of GDP) on R&D. Canada spends ten times more on R&D tax credits than it does on direct funding for R&D.

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Innovation Dublin

This year’s Innovation Dublin festival will take place from November 10th – 21st. For those 11 days, venues all over the city region will open their doors to showcase and promote innovation in the city.

From the Innovation Dublin website:

If you or your organization has an innovative idea, product, service, project or performance that you’d like to showcase as part of the festival, be sure submit your event and get involved!

A limited amount of meeting and exhibition space is being made available across the city during the festival – for networking events, exhibitions, talks and debates.

Innovation Dublin
Economic Development Unit,
Dublin City Council,
Civic Offices Wood Quay,
Dublin 8.

Sunday, July 04, 2010

OECD Innovation Policy

Via IrishEconomy blog, the OECD Innovation Strategy document was released recently. Links to the main documents and a summary are below. I think some of the people working in this area have started to talk about innovation the way certain music traditions talk about love. Sing it with me. "What the world needs now is innovation, sweet innovation..its the only thing that there's just too little of". Its worth reading this document and mentally substitute the words "love" or "loving" every time you see the words "innovation" or "innovative". Kept me going anyway.

Abstract
"The world today faces significant economic, environmental and social challenges. While no single policy instrument holds all the answers, innovation is the key ingredient of any effort to improve people’s quality of life. Today’s recovery from the global financial and economic crisis remains fragile. As countries seek to improve productivity performance and ensure sustained growth, they will need to boost their capacity to innovate. Innovation is also essential for addressing some of society’s most pressing issues, such as climate change, health and poverty. But how can governments encourage more people to innovation more of the time? And how can government itself be more innovative?"

Friday, March 12, 2010

Innovation Taskforce

The Innovation Taskforce document was released yesterday. This is an important document that has been somewhat overshadowed today by an ongoing health story. It is important that all the proposals in this document  be debated across different groups and media. It contains a lot of material about the connections between education and innovation, school and college curricula, tax incentives, economies of scale and so on that I have not fully digested yet, so I will put it up here for now and discuss further in the next few days.

Friday, October 09, 2009

NBER Book on Science and Engineering Careers

Many of these papers are available as working papers and so on and overall a really useful collection for people interested in research careers, science and technology policy and so on.

link here.

Monday, September 28, 2009

What’s Smart About Ireland’s Smart Economy?

This is the title of an RIA event to be held at City Hall, Dame Street, Dublin 2 on Wednesday, 14 October 2009, at 6pm. More details are available on the RIA website here (scroll down to #4). The event is sponsored by the Higher Education Authority and is part of Innovation Dublin Week 2009. It is jointly organised with Dublin City Council.

Chair: Professor Michael Cronin MRIA

Panellists: Professor Peter Clinch, Taoiseach’s special adviser on the smart economy, David O’Meara, Managing Director of Havok, Jim Barry, CEO, National Toll Roads, Professor Frances Ruane, MRIA, Director of the Economic and Social Research Institute and Tom Boland, CEO of the Higher Education Authority

Tuesday, September 01, 2009

Science and Technology Policy

Some recent defences of spending on science and technology in Ireland have come from Professor Luke O'Neill (if you look closely at this post you will see a remarkable slip of the tongue by yours truly) and Frank Gannon, Director of SFI.

These introduce a number of things into debate. O'Neill's argument brings in the research of Murphy and Topel examining the benefits of medical research, something that should be read by anyone serious about this debate. Gannon directs the debate specifically toward the functioning of large SFI programmes such as CSET's and Strategic Research Clusters. It is extremely welcome that these terms are now starting to enter the debate as ultimately this is what taxpayers are funding and ultimately the success of these initiatives or otherwise will determine whether the investment has been worthwhile. The comment below clearly is something that merits further comment and in general a more open debate about the specific outputs of IRCSET, IRCHSS, SFI, PRTLI and so on would advance this public discussion a great deal.

"The impact of the CSETs is well recognized and we are confident that the same will be true of the SRCs in a short time. In fact, the surprising result that SFI can report is that its investments when looked at as a portfolio have yielded positive commercial results in a 3-5 year period"

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Social Capital and Innovation - ter Weel and Akcomak

How do social capital and government support affect innovation and growth? Evidence from the EU regional support programmes

Author info | Abstract | Publisher info | Download info | Related research | Statistics
Author Info
Akcomak, Semih (akcomak@merit.unu.edu) (UNU-MERIT)
Ter Weel, Bas (b.terweel@merit.unimaas.nl) (UNU-MERIT)
Additional information is available for the following registered author(s):

Bas ter Weel
Ibrahim Akcomak

This research investigates the role of social capital and government intervention in explaining the differences of innovation output and economic growth for regions of the European Union from 1990-2002. Using several measures of social capital and innovation, and the European Union’s Objective 1, 2 and 5b figures for EU regional support, the estimates suggest that EU funding is not significantly contributing to economic outcomes, while social capital is. Investigation of a possible complementary relationship between social capital and government support reveals that regions with higher levels of social capital are more likely to effectively gain from EU regional support programmes. This result implies that aside from the benefits associated with the direct effect of social capital on economic outcomes, social capital appears to be a critical prerequisite for the effective implementation of government programmes. From a policy perspective, it appears to be important to stimulate education to foster human capital formation. When combined, human capital and social capital are likely to yield stronger effects for effective policies which increase economic outcomes

Saturday, August 22, 2009

Featured Researcher: Adam Jaffe

The work of Brandeis Professor and NBER Fellow Adam Jaffe is well worth reading in connection with the ongoing debate on Science policy. His IDEAS page is below. His work examines evaluation of research funding in a number of areas.

link to IDEAS page

An example of his approach is below (may require subscription)

The ‘‘Science of Science Policy’’: reflections on the important questions and the challenges they present

Adam B. Jaffe

Abstract

Developing the ‘‘Science of Science Policy’’ will require data collection and analysis related to the processes of innovation and technological change, and the effects of government policy on those processes. There has been much work on these topics in the last three decades, but there remain difficult problems of finding proxies for subtle con-
cepts, endogeneity, distinguishing private and social returns, untangling cumulative effects, measuring the impact of government programs in a true ‘‘but for’’ sense, and sorting out national and global effects. I offer observations on how to think about these issues.

Toward a debate on Science and Technology Policy in Ireland

There has been a large amount of activity in recent weeks debating the extent to which the government should support science and technology in the universities, and the likely impact that such spending will have on the wider economy and society and through which particular channels.

Some of this debate is a continuation of a long-standing discussion on two government strategy documents, the "Strategy for Science, Technology and Innovation" and the "Framework for Economic Renewal" (Smart Economy) document.

Discussion has also likely increased as a result of the opinion expressed in the McCarthy report that there was little evidence of value deriving from R+D activities. The McCarthy report opinion on university research funding is below.

"The two research councils, Irish Research Council for the Humanities and Social Science (IRCHSS) and Irish Research Council for Science, Engineering and Technology (IRCSET) provide funding for researchers in the form of post graduate scholarships, post doctoral fellowships, research fellowships and project based research. The Group supports the CEEU recommendation that the industry co-funding ratio should be increased for IRCSET’s enterprise partnership awards. Further, the Group is of the view that the allocation to the research councils to increase Ph.D. outputs should be reduced because of the uncertainty about the absorptive capacity of industry to employ fourth level graduates and the propensity of Ph.D. graduates to emigrate. The fifth cycle of the PRTLI scheme is due to run over the period 2010 to 2014. This scheme has been in operation since 1998 and there is insufficient evidence of the positive economic impact of the programme to date. Subject to any contractual commitments, this cycle should be cancelled. This will lead to savings in future years as spending on earlier cycles of PRTLI winds down without any new funding requirements arising in their place. The cancellation should also have imfor SFIfunding given that SFI researchers are housed in PRTLI funded infrastructure."

A number of economists have written critical articles about the current direction of S+T policy:

Eoin O'Leary

Karl Whelan

Kevin O'Rourke

Richard Tol

MIchael Hennigan

A number of further articles have defended large scale funding of university research

Luke O'Neill

Ferdinand von Prondzynksi

The importance of this debate cannot be understated, not least for people (many of whom read this blog) who have devoted most of their lives to research and teaching in university contexts. The charge of being a "vested interest" is frequently hurled at people who express opinions in this area. But anyone who works in a university or in research has a vested interest in this, and we have to try to deal with that and put forward coherent views that can be debated. If the charge is true that no-one working in research can express an objective view about how it should be funded and structured then we all should stop now.

It has also been agreed by many on both sides of the debate that if you simply start counting direct revenue generated from university patenting and licensing activities, that you are not going to find a good justification for funding research in universities, certainly not a healthy economic return. It seems to me obvious that Ferdinand von Prondzynski's point is correct that indirect rather than direct measures of benefits from research funding needed to be prioritised. To that extent, we need to start talking about issues such as:

- whether research funding in a university improves the quality and return to education in that university. Related to this, do students who are taught by and interact with top researchers become better equipped to work with cutting edge technologies and so on.

- the extent to which having research groups in Ireland that are embedded into international networks has value is something again I want to debate without assumption. many of us here base a huge amount of our working life on the (untested) assumption that working with international colleagues who are excellent in their field improves our work and improves the quality of knowledge in our respective fields in Ireland. the thing that impresses me when I see some of the better SFI-funded programmes is the international networks that such programmes open up to people in Irish universities. I have to admit that I have always viewed this as having huge value and this is my default assumption. having said that, to argue that a huge amount of money should be spent on developing these networks on the basis of an assumption would be silly.

- the extent to which multinational companies based location decisions on factors such as PhD researchers available, ability to draw from local research groups and so on.

- the extent to which indigenous companies can draw expertise and tools from research clusters based in universities. how much is this happening in Ireland at present?

- the extent to which research funding potentially improves non-market outcomes. For example, to what extent does funding Irish health research impact on hospital functioning and on the integration of global technologies into Irish healthcare. Every time this get's mentioned somebody makes a scoffing remark. My instinct (completely open to being tested and just an opinion) is that medical consultants who are conducting leading edge research (even if in specific areas) are constantly thinking about where modern health technologies are developing and are better equipped to integrate global technologies. Testing this in the Irish case would be very difficult but it is certainly a channel that we would be stupid to dismiss without thinking further about it.

From the point of view of economists, our role is not just to shoot down every claim that isn't 100 per cent backed up. It is also to examine potential channels that generate increases in human welfare and to think about testing them. We should try to put all of the chess pieces on the board before getting fully started on this.

Learning from Outsiders

James Markusen and Natalia Trofimenko have a recent paper on how local workers learn from foreign firms (NBER Version below)

Teaching locals new tricks: Foreign experts as a channel of knowledge transmission

Markusen, James R.
Trofimenko, Natalia

Gains from productivity and knowledge transmission arising from the presence of foreign firms have received a good deal of empirical attention, but theoretical micro-foundations for this mechanism are limited. Here we develop a model in which foreign experts may train domestic workers who work with them. Hypotheses are generated under the assumptions that workers learn from experts (the effect of using an expert is not strictly temporary) and that this learning is embodied in the workers rather than in the firm. We use fixed effects and nearest neighbor matching estimators on a panel of plant-level data for Colombia that identifies the use of foreign experts, to show that these experts have substantial and persistent positive effects (though not always immediate) on the wages of domestic workers and on the value added per worker.

Friday, August 21, 2009

Yale Lecture on Innovation

A fun Yale lecture on Innovation. It outlines techniques developed in a book called "why not" by Professor Barry Nalebuff. Nice overlap with behavioural economics. Includes some interesting product development ideas such as airport valet parking and pay-as-you-go insurance as well as auto-refinancing mortgages. The solution to grade inflation of putting the class grade distribution for each subject and the average GPA of the students taking each class on each transcript seems good to me at first glance. The part about how to peel a banana is a little outside the scope of behavioural economics but that is really cool (26 minutes in).

http://academicearth.org/lectures/why_not

Research Funding, Multinational Investment and Indigenous Business

If anyone is interested in testing the proposition below, let me know. I think that Professor Prondzynksi hits the nail on the head. However, nobody has conducted a serious statistical study rigorously examining the extent to which research funding causally impacted the development of multinational investment and indigenous start-ups in Ireland, and how the Irish experience compares internationally.

"For example, the IDA (Ireland’s inward investment agency) has stated several times that its recent successes in generating foreign direct investment have overwhelmingly dependent on and been based on our research investment and the existence of a serious research community in Ireland, as this was a vital factor for the companies contemplating Ireland. Similarly, indigenous start-ups increasingly tap into our research capacity."

Creating an Environment for Commercialisation

Ferdindand von Prondzynksi makes a strong case on his blog that the focus on direct immediate commercialisation of research findings is misplaced. The article is linked below.

http://universitydiary.wordpress.com/2009/08/21/research-economics-and-trench-warfare/

This is a very timely contribution that helps to move the debate on. As evidenced by the quotes below, the focus of the argument is that research funding for universities creates an environment where research innovation can flourish if not by direct commercialisation itself but through outside actors drawing from the knowledge created. An example given in the article is the research triangle in North Carolina.

"What annoys me is that this debate is often being conducted around the idea that research should create jobs, meaning that there should be immediate spin-offs that generate large-scale employment."

"For example, the IDA (Ireland’s inward investment agency) has stated several times that its recent successes in generating foreign direct investment have overwhelmingly dependent on and been based on our research investment and the existence of a serious research community in Ireland, as this was a vital factor for the companies contemplating Ireland. Similarly, indigenous start-ups increasingly tap into our research capacity. In that sense, the complaint noted by Michael Hennigan that post-doctoral researchers don’t go into business but move on to other research projects is of no significance, in that researchers are rarely the right people to go into business – but they need to go on to help create further discovery that can then be used by those who have the business skills."

It is difficult to agree with the final conclusion below however. This is for a number of reasons. Firstly, it is not at all clear that the various SSTI and Smart Economy initiatives have the same vision as outlined above, and it is certainly worth continuing to debate what is being achieved in these initiatives and what is trying to be achieved. The professor is right to point out that this should not be done from the default position of assuming that research is a worthless activity but I think the amount of economists who hold that view is a lot smaller than he gives credit for. If we can agree that creating an environment where linkages both direct and indirect to universities lead to widespread societal and economic innovation driven in both directions (we learn in universities also by looking outwards), then it still is vital to ask what form these linkages are now taking and what role funding mechanisms play in this. What mechanisms best promote these linkages? Are the ones that we have in place optimal? What direct and indirect costs and benefits accrue when government agencies fund research? In general, it would be good to bring some of this debate to specifics and I am going to begin to start focusing some posts on specific questions related to this debate.

"The evidence is clear and is well known. It is time to stop pretending that we don’t have the facts. It’s time to be focused and determined, and to show consistency of purpose. Unless we like the idea of going back to the 1980s"