Showing posts with label intelligence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intelligence. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Smart boy wanted: longevity and intelligence

Economists are interested in the returns to cognitive ability. One fairly basic return is longevity: smarter people live longer. But why? An obvious explanation is that they make better choices, avoiding the Darwin Awards for example. A more specific hypothesis is that they cope better with adversity and hence live longer. Some experimental evidence is detailed here. Don't worry: it uses bees.

Monday, December 13, 2010

The height of intelligence

The positive correlation between height and intelligence has been documented many times. It is attributed generally to deficits in early life nutrition. According to some this explains much of the height/earnings premium. So is there any evidence on this correlation for Ireland? Using the Growing Up in Ireland data I graph the students mathematics score against their height (adjusting for sex, SES and birthweight) along with a 95% confidence interval.
So yes there is a slight upward gradient but it flattens out above about 1.25 metres, possibly even dipping at the very top of the range, the raw correlation is .114. But on the whole it looks fairly flat and shorter people who want to be mathematicians should not be discouraged.

Wednesday, November 28, 2007

Literacy not intelligence moderates the relationships between economic development, income inequality and health

Abstract:Objectives. Kanazawa (2006) presented data allegedly supporting a racist version of evolutionary psychology that claims that the populations of wealthier and more egalitarian societies live longer and stay healthier, not because they are wealthier and more egalitarian, but because they are more intelligent. The objectives of this study are: (i) to determine the relationship between IQ and literacy in Kanazawa's sample of countries and (ii) to reanalyse Kanazawa's dataset using measures of literacy in lieu of national IQ test scores.

Method. Correlation and regression were employed.
Results. National literacy scores across the countries in the sample are highly skewed. In spite of this, the literacy measures are highly correlated with alleged differences in national IQ (r = .83-.86). The measure of literacy together with economic development (GDPpc) and income inequality (Gini coefficient) control at least 59-64% of the variance in national life expectancy at birth.

Conclusions. There is no scientific justification for believing that alleged intelligence differences play any role in explaining international differences in health status. Measures of alleged national IQ scores are highly confounded with differences in literacy. Literacy is a key factor in the health of any community and policies designed to enhance the literacy of a population are expected to lead to significant improvements in health status.

Marks (2007)


The Kanazawa paper 'IQ and the wealth of states' and his paper Mind the gapin intelligence: Re-examining the relationship between inequality and health have been criticised in several papers:

Dickins et al. (2007)

Kanazawa (2006) has put forward an evolutionarily grounded theory which claims that individuals in wealthier and more egalitarian societies live longer and stay healthier not because they are wealthier or more egalitarian but because they are more intelligent (2006: 637). The claim rests on an argument which asserts that general intelligence is a solution to evolutionarily novel problems and that most dangers to health in contemporary society are evolutionarily novel. Kanazawa also claims that this relationship does not hold in sub-Saharan Africa. These claims are based on a cross-national analysis which finds a positive correlation between 'national' IQ scores and mortality data. The implication is that intelligence is the principal factor determining longevity in the rest of the world, regardless of issues such as adequacy of diet and availability of health care. Kanazawa's theoretical claims about the evolution of general intelligence as a domain-specific adaptation are inconsistent with adaptationist analysis: natural selection does not solve general problems. The assumptions that sub-Saharan Africa is more representative of the evolutionary past than is the rest of the world, and that most hazards to health in contemporary society are evolutionarily novel, are implausible. The methods used are inadequate because Kanazawa argues for causation from correlation and fails to consider alternative explanations. The IQ data are flawed for reasons to do with sample size and sampling, extrapolation and inconsistency across measures. Nor are they temporally compatible with the economic and demographic data

From Geoff (2007)
Kanazawa concludes that `wealthier and more egalitarian societies live longer and stay healthier … because they are more intelligent'. The result does not apply to sub-Saharan Africa, but this exception is explained by reference to his theory of evolutionary psychology, `The Savanna Principle'. We reanalyse the data, taking into account non-linearity in the relationship of GDP to life expectancy and find that the results no longer support his conclusions. We also argue that HIV prevalence rates are a more parsimonious explanation for differences between sub-Saharan Africa and elsewhere.

Monday, November 19, 2007

Adolescents’ performance on delay and probability discounting tasks: Age, intelligence, executive functioning, externalising behaviour

This study reflects the attempt to integrate delay discounting into existing psychological models around executive functioning, intelligence, and emotional regulation.

Abstract:
Healthy adolescents, ages 9–23, completed delay and probability discounting tasks and measures of verbal and non-verbal intelligence, executive functioning, and self-reported internalizing and externalizing behavior. Delay but not probability discounting decreased with age. Delay discounting was also associated with verbal intelligence and Go–NoGo and Iowa Gambling Task performance. Probability discounting was associated only with externalizing behavior. Findings conform to an accumulation of evidence that while delay and probability discounting may have some overlapping components, they also reflect some fundamentally different processes in this age group.

They found a nice correlation of .35 between delay discounting and errors of commission (responding on a no-go trial) indicating that the ability to inhibit a response is very much central to delay discounting. The authors are pointing to IQ as the main variable in accounting for differences in delay discounting as this is in line with the de Wit et al (2007) study which had a larger sample. For parsimony and methodological reasons I would have liked to have seen the Go-NoGo variable put into the regression before IQ as it was correlated to a greater extent with delay discounting and it is possible that it is tapping into a fundamental process which is central to the development and operation of intelligence. The discussion was framed completely around this contribution of IQ which may have been an artefact of what looked to me a biased regression procedure.

The finding in regard to IQ echoes some recent larger scale retrospective epidemiological studies showing that lower childhood IQ increases the chance of mortality in middle-age and that this is largely due to an increased likelihood of engaging persistently in health risk behaviours: Childhood IQ in relation to risk factors for premature mortality in middle-aged persons: the Aberdeen Children of the 1950s study. I wonder will Go-NoGo performance predict mortality in 40 years.. It's a terribly tedious task to complete for anyone who's had the opportunity but you have to consider the benefits of examining such a basic process in comparison to something like IQ which is such a broad concept that doesn't translate easily to theory-related neuronal processes unless you go through the medium of executive function..

Olson et al. (2007). Adolescents’ performance on delay and probabilitydiscounting tasks: Contributions of age, intelligence, executive functioning, and self-reported externalizing behavior

Tuesday, April 24, 2007

Are Risk Aversion and Impatience Related to Cognitive Ability?

Thomas Dohmen (IZA) , Armin Falk (IZA, University of Bonn and CEPR), David Huffman (IZA) , Uwe Sunde (IZA, University of Bonn and CEPR)

URL: http://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:iza:izadps:dp2735&r=cbe
Is the way that people make risky choices, or tradeoffs over time, related to cognitive ability? This paper investigates whether there is a link between cognitive ability, risk aversion, and impatience, using a representative sample of the population and incentive compatible measures. We conduct choice experiments measuring risk aversion, and impatience over an annual time horizon, for a randomly drawn sample of roughly 1,000 German adults. Subjects also take part in two different tests of cognitive ability, which correspond to sub-modules of one of the most widely used IQ tests. Interviews are conducted in subjects' own homes. We find that lower cognitive ability is associated with significantly more impatient behavior in the experiments, and with greater risk aversion. This relationship is robust to controlling for personal characteristics, educational attainment, income, and measures of credit constraints.